This is post 6 in the series "Essential Informal Learning for Any Degree Program" by Saul Carliner which offers several concrete suggestions for extracurricular activities to recommend and to students and details how to direct students to the choices most appropriate for them.
In addition to regularly sharing their knowledge through presentations, one of the leadership expectations of people with master’s and doctoral degrees is that they also share their expertise with their organizations and their colleagues through formal publications. In other words, they should write articles intended for the peer-reviewed and professional publications named in an earlier post.
What types of articles can students publish?
- For professional publications, these can include tips and tricks articles, which offer suggestions on how to perform tasks used on the job, interviews with thought leaders, case studies of real-world projects, analyses that help practicing professionals put concepts into perspective, and summaries of relevant research—often presented as heuristics (specific rules) that suggest how to specifically apply this research.
- For academic publications, these can include book reviews, integrative literature reviews that provide a consolidated report on the state of the literature in a particular area (a great way to report findings from the literature review of a thesis or dissertation); reports of empirical research (either the student’s own work or a co-author credit on a project led by the professor); and a theory article, which provides a new perspective on the field that emerges from an examination of the empirical research.
Table 1 suggests some specific formats to recommend to students.
Table 1: Potential Publishing Opportunities for Students
Workplace- Oriented Students |
Pre-Doctoral and Doctoral Students |
|
|
Where can students submit their articles?
Students can also publish in a variety of outlets. For professional publication, these include newsletters and websites (usually easiest to publish), magazines and webzines (next in difficulty), and reports.
For academic publication, these include several types of peer-reviewed sources, including book chapters and articles for peer-reviewed journals.
An additional challenge, however, is that each of these types of articles has a particular format and imposes a series of expectations on authors. These are expectations that many aspiring authors do not even realize exist.
Table 2 suggests some specific formats and publishing outlets to recommend to students.
Table 2: Potential Venues for Student Articles
Workplace- Oriented Students |
Pre-Doctoral and Doctoral Students |
|
|
How can I prepare students for the writing task?
To help students ease into these roles, provide class assignments in which students have an opportunity to try out one or more of these forms, sometimes with the goal of submitting the resulting publication for class. The class activity might explicitly identify the conventions used in particular types of articles (like the expectations of research article or how-to article) and provide students with several opportunities to develop drafts of such articles.
Why should I emphasize with students about the writing process?
Those several drafts suggest a second issue: emphasize the importance of revision to students. Most student papers are high stakes--they submit one draft for a grade. Many students just write the one draft. Most have never gone through the formal process of review and revision. Some see that process as torture rather than as one of continuous improvement. Providing formal opportunities for revision helps prepare them for the revision process typical in all aspects of our professional work.
How much publishing should I recommend?
The number and type of articles that students should publish varies, depending on the degree and their long-term goal:
- Suggest publishing to highly motivated bachelor’s students who have good communication skills as a stretch goal (not required but one intended to stretch a student beyond complacency). Newsletters and website articles provide perfect opportunities to launch their publishing “careers.”
- Recommend publishing to all master’s students. The experience provides a great developmental opportunity and looks good on their resumes. Students intending to go right into the work force should consider publishing one article in a professional newsletter, magazine or webzine. Those who plan to pursue doctoral studies might individually or co-author one publication for a peer-reviewed publication.
- Doctoral students should publish in both academic and professional venues. Research and theory articles in peer-reviewed publications are essential to academic employment. As many candidates for faculty positions enter the job market with these publications, those preparing for it should expect that they need them. So, they should have at least one, though three to five (some on which the student can serve as a co-author) is recommended.
But publishing in professional magazines and webzines is equally important, especially in an applied field like ours, in which practitioners are not only the ultimate recipients of research-based advice, but often the subjects of the research. Because research tends towards the theoretical and follows precise rules that hold little interest to practicing professionals, many of them difficulty understanding research-based publications. By writing for practicing professionals, aspiring researchers have the incentive to explain their research in language accessible to the average training and development professional.
Final Tip: To learn more about different types of informal learning activities, check out chapters 5 and 6 of the new book, Informal Learning Basics from ASTD Press.
