ATD, association for talent development

ATD Blog

3 Tips for Successful Mentoring Conversations

By

Tue Jun 18 2019

3 Tips for Successful Mentoring Conversations
Loading...

Content

The fast pace of technological advancements can make it hard to remember that it was only in 2007 that the first iPhone was released or just 2004 that Facebook was founded. Can you imagine your life without a smartphone in your hand or social media at your fingertips?

The fast pace of technological advancements can make it hard to remember that it was only in 2007 that the first iPhone was released or just 2004 that Facebook was founded. Can you imagine your life without a smartphone in your hand or social media at your fingertips?

Content

Mentoring software , which came onto the scene in the early 2000s, was revolutionary much in the same way; it provided an easier way for people to find a mentor and take part in mentoring relationships. While this software provides technology to help make the process more streamlined and accessible, though, the heart of a mentoring relationship is shaped by the people within it. Even with technology helping to facilitate matches and keep people focused on their goals, we can’t forget that the real magic happens during the mentoring conversations.

Mentoring software, which came onto the scene in the early 2000s, was revolutionary much in the same way; it provided an easier way for people to find a mentor and take part in mentoring relationships. While this software provides technology to help make the process more streamlined and accessible, though, the heart of a mentoring relationship is shaped by the people within it. Even with technology helping to facilitate matches and keep people focused on their goals, we can’t forget that the real magic happens during the mentoring conversations.

Content

What makes mentoring such a special process? Consider these three things:

What makes mentoring such a special process? Consider these three things:

  • Content

    Humanity and humility that people bring with them to their relationships gives mentoring its power.

    Humanity and humility that people bring with them to their relationships gives mentoring its power.

  • Content

    Conversations between people put ideas and learning into context.

    Conversations between people put ideas and learning into context.

  • Content

    Support between mentees and mentors provides the strength people need to overcome hurdles and learn from mistakes.

    Support between mentees and mentors provides the strength people need to overcome hurdles and learn from mistakes.

Content

When you pull those factors together, you can create powerful mentoring relationships that impact people’s lives and careers—not to mention the impacts that can occur within organizations.

When you pull those factors together, you can create powerful mentoring relationships that impact people’s lives and careers—not to mention the impacts that can occur within organizations.

Content

To make the most of your mentoring conversations and build meaningful relationships, follow these three tips:

To make the most of your mentoring conversations and build meaningful relationships, follow these three tips:

Content

1. Create a Rhythm and Flow

1. Create a Rhythm and Flow

Content

Conversations between mentees and mentors represent the foundation of mentoring relationships and provide a mechanism for development to occur. The quality of these conversations will directly impact the value they have on the mentee’s development.

Conversations between mentees and mentors represent the foundation of mentoring relationships and provide a mechanism for development to occur. The quality of these conversations will directly impact the value they have on the mentee’s development.

Content

Mentoring conversations should have a rhythm and flow. This occurs by having a set pattern to the conversations that you can use time and again. Each time you meet with your mentee or mentor, talk about:

Mentoring conversations should have a rhythm and flow. This occurs by having a set pattern to the conversations that you can use time and again. Each time you meet with your mentee or mentor, talk about:

  • Content

    what actions were taken since your last meeting

    what actions were taken since your last meeting

  • Content

    what worked

    what worked

  • Content

    what didn’t work

    what didn’t work

  • Content

    what you could try next

    what you could try next

  • Content

    where you go from here.

    where you go from here.

Content

This becomes a cyclical conversation model that you can follow throughout the relationship. By focusing on the smaller action items, you will progress toward larger goals.

This becomes a cyclical conversation model that you can follow throughout the relationship. By focusing on the smaller action items, you will progress toward larger goals.

2. Turn Conversations Into Actions

Content

Talking about issues and concerns with your mentoring partner creates the foundation of your mentoring relationship but talking can take things only so far. To make mentoring conversations more meaningful to personal development, end every critical conversation with a commitment to take a specific action. Here are three ways you can accomplish this:

Talking about issues and concerns with your mentoring partner creates the foundation of your mentoring relationship but talking can take things only so far. To make mentoring conversations more meaningful to personal development, end every critical conversation with a commitment to take a specific action. Here are three ways you can accomplish this:

Content

Be goal-oriented.

Be goal-oriented.

  • Content

    Mentees: Prioritize activities and ideas that can improve your skills or abilities and ultimately bring you closer to your mentoring goals.

    Mentees: Prioritize activities and ideas that can improve your skills or abilities and ultimately bring you closer to your mentoring goals.

  • Content

    Mentors: Consider asking “Why?” for each idea or action that arises so you can ensure it helps move the mentee toward their stated goals. This will also give them the chance to express their reasoning and thoughts behind each action.

    Mentors: Consider asking “Why?” for each idea or action that arises so you can ensure it helps move the mentee toward their stated goals. This will also give them the chance to express their reasoning and thoughts behind each action.

Content

Be practical.

Be practical.

  • Content

    Mentees: Attempt to apply new learning or awareness in a common and straightforward way. Take on actions that put the basic principles of your conversation into play and report back to your mentor regarding your experience and observations to stimulate further discussion.

    Mentees: Attempt to apply new learning or awareness in a common and straightforward way. Take on actions that put the basic principles of your conversation into play and report back to your mentor regarding your experience and observations to stimulate further discussion.

  • Content

    Mentors: Walk through ideas with your mentee so they can see how to apply them in the real world. Encourage open discussions on what worked and what didn’t.

    Mentors: Walk through ideas with your mentee so they can see how to apply them in the real world. Encourage open discussions on what worked and what didn’t.

Content

Be a model.

Be a model.

  • Content

    Mentees: As you engage in conversations with your mentor, consider how the concepts under discussion will affect your current behavior. If you were to adopt a new standard of behavior, what changes would have to take place?

    Mentees: As you engage in conversations with your mentor, consider how the concepts under discussion will affect your current behavior. If you were to adopt a new standard of behavior, what changes would have to take place?

  • Content

    Mentors: Give honest feedback on your observations of their behavior and, if possible, share personal insights from your own experiences with adopting the new behaviors or techniques under discussion. Show them how you walked this path and what you learned from the experience.

    Mentors: Give honest feedback on your observations of their behavior and, if possible, share personal insights from your own experiences with adopting the new behaviors or techniques under discussion. Show them how you walked this path and what you learned from the experience.

3. Give Thanks

Content

Taking the time to explicitly state why you are grateful to be in the mentoring relationship can be a great conversation starter. It can also help build trust and rapport between you as you openly express gratitude.

Taking the time to explicitly state why you are grateful to be in the mentoring relationship can be a great conversation starter. It can also help build trust and rapport between you as you openly express gratitude.

Content

Do you tell your mentee or mentor the things they have brought to your life and the relationship? Do you take the time to share specific examples of what it is about your mentee or mentor that makes you appreciate them? Do you express how they have impacted your work?

Do you tell your mentee or mentor the things they have brought to your life and the relationship? Do you take the time to share specific examples of what it is about your mentee or mentor that makes you appreciate them? Do you express how they have impacted your work?

Content

People tend to feel closer to one another when they open up and express real emotions. That can play a key role in forging a solid foundation in your mentoring relationship.

People tend to feel closer to one another when they open up and express real emotions. That can play a key role in forging a solid foundation in your mentoring relationship.

Content

Consider these conversation starters that you can use with your mentee or mentor to begin expressing your gratitude:

Consider these conversation starters that you can use with your mentee or mentor to begin expressing your gratitude:

  • Content

    I am grateful for . . .

    I am grateful for . . .

  • Content

    I appreciate when you . . .

    I appreciate when you . . .

  • Content

    I find it helpful when you . . .

    I find it helpful when you . . .

  • Content

    I value you and try to show you by . . .

    I value you and try to show you by . . .

  • Content

    Your partnership with me means . . .

    Your partnership with me means . . .

  • Content

    Our conversations help me . . .

    Our conversations help me . . .

  • Content

    Your personality/attitude/insights/experience/openness helps me . . .

    Your personality/attitude/insights/experience/openness helps me . . .

  • Content

    This relationship has given me . . .

    This relationship has given me . . .

Content

Expressing genuine gratitude can strengthen your relationship. It can also help you build your character as you strive to show appreciation as well as give you a renewed sense of commitment to your mentee or mentor.

Expressing genuine gratitude can strengthen your relationship. It can also help you build your character as you strive to show appreciation as well as give you a renewed sense of commitment to your mentee or mentor.

Content

As you continue on your mentoring journey, remember that mentoring is a personal relationship between humans and that fostering better mentoring conversations can help you achieve success.

As you continue on your mentoring journey, remember that mentoring is a personal relationship between humans and that fostering better mentoring conversations can help you achieve success.

You've Reached ATD Member-only Content

Become an ATD member to continue

Already a member?Sign In


Copyright © 2026 ATD

ASTD changed its name to ATD to meet the growing needs of a dynamic, global profession.

Terms of UsePrivacy NoticeCookie Policy