ATD Blog
All In: White Men Needed for Diversity & Inclusion
Fri Jan 09 2015
Content
For many, Diversity & Inclusion (D&I) is designed to address the specific concerns, inequities, and bias experienced by underrepresented groups (such as women, people of color, LGBT, people with disabilities and others) who have not had equal access to opportunity and face unique barriers, compared with the “pale and male.” With the U.S. population rapidly becoming majority non-white , shifts in attitudes, buying power, are relationships are inevitable; successful organizations will harness these changes to grow and innovate, as well as attract, retain, and develop talent and mirror the communities in which they operate.
For many, Diversity & Inclusion (D&I) is designed to address the specific concerns, inequities, and bias experienced by underrepresented groups (such as women, people of color, LGBT, people with disabilities and others) who have not had equal access to opportunity and face unique barriers, compared with the “pale and male.” With the U.S. population rapidly becoming majority non-white, shifts in attitudes, buying power, are relationships are inevitable; successful organizations will harness these changes to grow and innovate, as well as attract, retain, and develop talent and mirror the communities in which they operate.
Content
Advances in D&I have been painfully slow; some research suggests that there has actually been a deceleration in progress. White men are 68 percent more likely to hold leadership roles in the private sector, which is most prevalent at the executive ranks. According to The Study on White Men Leading Through Diversity & Inclusion white men are less engaged with D&I than diverse colleagues. As a major employee group that still largely retains the levers of power, not including white men means that any D&I initiative will achieve less than what is possible.
Advances in D&I have been painfully slow; some research suggests that there has actually been a deceleration in progress. White men are 68 percent more likely to hold leadership roles in the private sector, which is most prevalent at the executive ranks. According to The Study on White Men Leading Through Diversity & Inclusion white men are less engaged with D&I than diverse colleagues. As a major employee group that still largely retains the levers of power, not including white men means that any D&I initiative will achieve less than what is possible.
Content
The Polarities of D&I
The Polarities of D&I
Content
Any change involving deeply held beliefs and practices is challenging to implement. This is particularly true when we are addressing historical privileges and power. Too often, D&I initiatives are presented as an “either/or” issue, such as minority vs. majority needs. In fact, progress will be achieved by framing “both/and” polarities to be managed—a concept described by Barry Johnson .
Any change involving deeply held beliefs and practices is challenging to implement. This is particularly true when we are addressing historical privileges and power. Too often, D&I initiatives are presented as an “either/or” issue, such as minority vs. majority needs. In fact, progress will be achieved by framing “both/and” polarities to be managed—a concept described by Barry Johnson.
Content
Failure to acknowledge and address the inherent complexities and manage the polarities of D&I does not produce desired results. Here are examples, in addition to the focus on diverse populations vs. white male inclusion, that illustrate inherent D&I polarities:
Failure to acknowledge and address the inherent complexities and manage the polarities of D&I does not produce desired results. Here are examples, in addition to the focus on diverse populations vs. white male inclusion, that illustrate inherent D&I polarities:
Content
Understanding differences vs. Emphasizing commonalities
Understanding differences vs. Emphasizing commonalities
Content
Addressing inequities vs. Avoiding stereotyping
Addressing inequities vs. Avoiding stereotyping
Content
Promoting diversity through policies vs. Encouraging authenticity
Promoting diversity through policies vs. Encouraging authenticity
Content
Measuring and tracking progress vs. Focus on numbers
Measuring and tracking progress vs. Focus on numbers
Content
Some obstacles to engaging with white men in D&I initiatives include:
Some obstacles to engaging with white men in D&I initiatives include:
Content
concern about investing limited resources in this group, assumed to be already enjoying great privileges
concern about investing limited resources in this group, assumed to be already enjoying great privileges
Content
avoiding discussions about relationship and power issues
avoiding discussions about relationship and power issues
Content
lack of white men’s comfort level interacting with others who are different
lack of white men’s comfort level interacting with others who are different
Content
lack of awareness that d&i includes white men.
lack of awareness that d&i includes white men.
Content
If the focus of D&I is exclusively on underrepresented groups, this may have the unintended consequence of fostering more exclusion, not less.
If the focus of D&I is exclusively on underrepresented groups, this may have the unintended consequence of fostering more exclusion, not less.
Content
Impact of Exclusion
Impact of Exclusion
Content
Recent research has revealed that the feeling of being excluded produces a perception of physical pain , with increased activity in the dorsal anterior cingulate and anterior insula regions in the brain that are activated by bodily pain. As far as your brain is concerned, a broken heart is not dissimilar from a broken arm.
Recent research has revealed that the feeling of being excluded produces a perception of physical pain, with increased activity in the dorsal anterior cingulate and anterior insula regions in the brain that are activated by bodily pain. As far as your brain is concerned, a broken heart is not dissimilar from a broken arm.
Content
If D&I initiatives are unintentionally promoting such reactions from white men, the likely result will be rejection, anger, or defensiveness and further retreat within their own cohort—none of which will promote needed progress in creating more inclusive environments.
If D&I initiatives are unintentionally promoting such reactions from white men, the likely result will be rejection, anger, or defensiveness and further retreat within their own cohort—none of which will promote needed progress in creating more inclusive environments.
Content
Why White Men Are Needed
Why White Men Are Needed
Content
White men are a critical part of every organization’s D&I journey. Exclusionary practices tend to promote an insiders” and “outsiders” mentality. Typically, members of the dominant group are viewed as distinct individuals, while outsiders are stereotyped and viewed as homogeneous.
White men are a critical part of every organization’s D&I journey. Exclusionary practices tend to promote an insiders” and “outsiders” mentality. Typically, members of the dominant group are viewed as distinct individuals, while outsiders are stereotyped and viewed as homogeneous.
Content
A big driver for social progress is proximity, shared goals, and organizational norms. When people interact with others who are different, have a need to work together; and see that the organization requires working well across various elements of diversity, comfort and trust are built over time—creating a virtuous cycle of integration and acceptance.
A big driver for social progress is proximity, shared goals, and organizational norms. When people interact with others who are different, have a need to work together; and see that the organization requires working well across various elements of diversity, comfort and trust are built over time—creating a virtuous cycle of integration and acceptance.
Content
In The Study on White Men Leading Through Diversity & Inclusion, nearly 80 percent of respondents report that white male leaders are able to show respect for diverse co-workers. But the same study also showed that only 36 percent of white male respondents are “quite” or “extremely” effective in demonstrating candor with diverse co-workers, suggesting that there are multiple factors at hand that limit their full participation in D&I progress.
In The Study on White Men Leading Through Diversity & Inclusion, nearly 80 percent of respondents report that white male leaders are able to show respect for diverse co-workers. But the same study also showed that only 36 percent of white male respondents are “quite” or “extremely” effective in demonstrating candor with diverse co-workers, suggesting that there are multiple factors at hand that limit their full participation in D&I progress.
Content
Understanding Root Causes: Will And Skill
Understanding Root Causes: Will And Skill
Content
It’s important to assess the multiple factors holding white men back from embracing D&I in your organization. I suggest revisiting the work of Robert Mager and Peter Pipe , classic thinkers in the field of training and development who developed a methodology for assessing reasons for “non-performance” that applies.
It’s important to assess the multiple factors holding white men back from embracing D&I in your organization. I suggest revisiting the work of Robert Mager and Peter Pipe, classic thinkers in the field of training and development who developed a methodology for assessing reasons for “non-performance” that applies.
Content
Let’s start by taking a look at the issue of white male skill in D&I:
Let’s start by taking a look at the issue of white male skill in D&I:
Content
Is it primarily a lack of awareness?
Is it primarily a lack of awareness?
Content
Is it a lack of skills to be able to conduct candid conversations and promote greater understanding? ?
Is it a lack of skills to be able to conduct candid conversations and promote greater understanding? ?
Content
Is it a lack of knowledge about what to do?
Is it a lack of knowledge about what to do?
Content
Another key issue is will :
Another key issue is will:
Content
Do white men want to change?
Do white men want to change?
Content
Is it a lack of desire to make meaningful change happen?
Is it a lack of desire to make meaningful change happen?
Content
Is there a feeling that this is a zero-sum game?
Is there a feeling that this is a zero-sum game?
Content
It is likely that the root causes will be a combination, suggesting that future initiatives should involve self-awareness, feedback, skill building, rewards and creating accountability for change. Bottom line: to build meaningful change for D&I, white men must be part of the solution.
It is likely that the root causes will be a combination, suggesting that future initiatives should involve self-awareness, feedback, skill building, rewards and creating accountability for change. Bottom line: to build meaningful change for D&I, white men must be part of the solution.
Content
Action Steps
Action Steps
Content
Here are 10 steps that can promote a fully inclusive workplace, which promotes greater understanding at all levels and by all employees so we can harness the best efforts of all:
Here are 10 steps that can promote a fully inclusive workplace, which promotes greater understanding at all levels and by all employees so we can harness the best efforts of all:
Content
Integrate D&I in all leadership development efforts.
Integrate D&I in all leadership development efforts.
Content
Reward and recognize white male participation in Employee Resource Groups as an ally, supporter or sponsor.
Reward and recognize white male participation in Employee Resource Groups as an ally, supporter or sponsor.
Content
Promote reverse mentoring among diverse groups.
Promote reverse mentoring among diverse groups.
Content
Track year-over-year D&I progress.
Track year-over-year D&I progress.
Content
Reward white men for participating in sponsorship roles for underrepresented talent
Reward white men for participating in sponsorship roles for underrepresented talent
Content
Demonstrate the link between D&I, innovation and business success.
Demonstrate the link between D&I, innovation and business success.
Content
Promote the idea of a true meritocracy.
Promote the idea of a true meritocracy.
Content
Highlight success stories of white men who have been D&I champions—what they do, how they accomplish this and what the impact is.
Highlight success stories of white men who have been D&I champions—what they do, how they accomplish this and what the impact is.
Content
Promote D&I initiatives that manage inherent paradoxes.
Promote D&I initiatives that manage inherent paradoxes.
Content
Offer training to all that helps leaders to understand and include others who are different.
Offer training to all that helps leaders to understand and include others who are different.
Content
What actions do you take to ensure that your D&I programs are “all in?”
What actions do you take to ensure that your D&I programs are “all in?”