ATD, association for talent development

ATD Blog

Coached by Code: What Training My Coachbot Taught Me About Being Human

Content

Training an AI coach who sounded like me uncovered more than technical hurdles. It raised deeper questions about identity and integrity.

Training an AI coach who sounded like me uncovered more than technical hurdles. It raised deeper questions about identity and integrity.

By

Tue Oct 07 2025

Friendly positive cute cartoon orange robot with smiling face waving its hand. Chatbot greets. Customer support service chat bot. Robot assistant, online consultant. 3d illustration on blue background
Loading...

Content

When I agreed to co-create an AI-powered coaching platform , I thought the most significant challenge would be training the technology. After all, the goal was ambitious: Give employees a way to ask questions and get immediate coaching —anytime, anywhere—based on the expertise of multiple thought leaders, including me. My focus was simplification, innovation, and leading through change .

When I agreed to co-create an AI-powered coaching platform, I thought the most significant challenge would be training the technology. After all, the goal was ambitious: Give employees a way to ask questions and get immediate coaching—anytime, anywhere—based on the expertise of multiple thought leaders, including me. My focus was simplification, innovation, and leading through change.

Content

But as the project unfolded, I realized something unexpected. The real story wasn’t about building smarter technology. It was about what that technology reflected to us about being human.

But as the project unfolded, I realized something unexpected. The real story wasn’t about building smarter technology. It was about what that technology reflected to us about being human.

Why People Open Up to Machines

Content

AI coaching works for a surprisingly human reason: People feel safer talking to it.

AI coaching works for a surprisingly human reason: People feel safer talking to it.

Content

Research from MIT, USC, and the CISPA Helmholtz Center confirms what we saw firsthand—people often disclose more to an AI coach than to a human one. With no risk of judgment, embarrassment, or “silly” questions, they lean into candor. AI creates a space where honesty flows more freely, which makes it an unusually powerful tool for growth.

Research from MIT, USC, and the CISPA Helmholtz Center confirms what we saw firsthand—people often disclose more to an AI coach than to a human one. With no risk of judgment, embarrassment, or “silly” questions, they lean into candor. AI creates a space where honesty flows more freely, which makes it an unusually powerful tool for growth.

Content

And the benefits don’t stop there. A recent Korn Ferry study showed that 76 percent of global workers are more likely to stay when they have strong development opportunities . AI makes those opportunities widely accessible, extending coaching beyond executives and into every level of an organization.

And the benefits don’t stop there. A recent Korn Ferry study showed that 76 percent of global workers are more likely to stay when they have strong development opportunities. AI makes those opportunities widely accessible, extending coaching beyond executives and into every level of an organization.

Content

Even better, the technology can adapt in real time:

Even better, the technology can adapt in real time:

  • Content

    Tailoring guidance to roles, goals, or schedules

    Tailoring guidance to roles, goals, or schedules

  • Content

    Rehearsing tough conversations with employees or clients

    Rehearsing tough conversations with employees or clients

  • Content

    Giving live feedback in meetings or presentations

    Giving live feedback in meetings or presentations

  • Content

    Offering round-the-clock support on challenges like imposter syndrome or giving feedback

    Offering round-the-clock support on challenges like imposter syndrome or giving feedback

Content

It’s not hard to imagine the impact. Someone asks: “How do I disagree with my team without hurting morale?” or “Can you suggest three ways to simplify this strategy presentation?” The AI responds with concrete, contextual advice, echoing the perspective of actual leaders.

It’s not hard to imagine the impact. Someone asks: “How do I disagree with my team without hurting morale?” or “Can you suggest three ways to simplify this strategy presentation?” The AI responds with concrete, contextual advice, echoing the perspective of actual leaders.

Content

That was the vision—and the reason I lent my voice to it.

That was the vision—and the reason I lent my voice to it.

The Identity Check I Didn’t Expect

Content

However, training an AI coach who sounded like me uncovered more than technical hurdles. It raised deeper questions about identity and integrity.

However, training an AI coach who sounded like me uncovered more than technical hurdles. It raised deeper questions about identity and integrity.

Content

How could I be sure the advice was truly mine, not a distortion? Was the tone aligned with how I coach in real life—measured, empathetic, focused on lasting change? Could the system inadvertently deliver advice that was biased or cold, even harmful?

How could I be sure the advice was truly mine, not a distortion? Was the tone aligned with how I coach in real life—measured, empathetic, focused on lasting change? Could the system inadvertently deliver advice that was biased or cold, even harmful?

Content

One test case still stands out. A leader asked: “My team is resisting a new innovation initiative. What should I do?”

One test case still stands out. A leader asked: “My team is resisting a new innovation initiative. What should I do?”

Content

An AI response might be: “Reassign the resisters. Work only with fast adopters.”

An AI response might be: “Reassign the resisters. Work only with fast adopters.”

Content

On paper, that’s efficient. But it’s not leadership. True innovation is about inclusion , not exclusion—bringing people along, addressing fears, and creating cultural buy-in. Efficiency at the expense of empathy undermines the very change you’re trying to lead.

On paper, that’s efficient. But it’s not leadership. True innovation is about inclusion, not exclusion—bringing people along, addressing fears, and creating cultural buy-in. Efficiency at the expense of empathy undermines the very change you’re trying to lead.

Content

That’s when it became clear that my coachbot had to reflect not just my knowledge but also my values.

That’s when it became clear that my coachbot had to reflect not just my knowledge but also my values.

Content

We addressed this by feeding it updated materials, refining language, testing with difficult prompts, and auditing for “hallucinations”—those moments when AI offers confident misinformation. But even more, we worked to layer in empathy, context, and nuance, so the advice wasn’t just smart, it was human.

We addressed this by feeding it updated materials, refining language, testing with difficult prompts, and auditing for “hallucinations”—those moments when AI offers confident misinformation. But even more, we worked to layer in empathy, context, and nuance, so the advice wasn’t just smart, it was human.

The Art of Humanizing AI

Content

The lesson? AI doesn’t replace human connection. It needs to be guided by it.

The lesson? AI doesn’t replace human connection. It needs to be guided by it.

Content

We encouraged users to engage with the coach in ways that sparked richer dialogue. Prompts like:

We encouraged users to engage with the coach in ways that sparked richer dialogue. Prompts like:

  • Content

    “Lisa, what would you say if I feel overwhelmed but don’t want to admit weakness?”

    “Lisa, what would you say if I feel overwhelmed but don’t want to admit weakness?”

  • Content

    “Role-play firing someone—with empathy.”

    “Role-play firing someone—with empathy.”

  • Content

    “Show me how to push back on a senior exec’s bad idea—without burning bridges.”

    “Show me how to push back on a senior exec’s bad idea—without burning bridges.”

  • Content

    “Based on your innovation framework, what experiments should I try with my team this week?”

    “Based on your innovation framework, what experiments should I try with my team this week?”

  • Content

    “What’s one thing I could eliminate from my workflow to simplify?”

    “What’s one thing I could eliminate from my workflow to simplify?”

Content

These aren’t transactional questions. They invite simulation, perspective, and emotional intelligence—the ingredients that make coaching effective.

These aren’t transactional questions. They invite simulation, perspective, and emotional intelligence—the ingredients that make coaching effective.

What the Coachbot Taught Me

Content

In the beginning, I thought I’d be teaching the machine. In reality, the machine was teaching me—about leadership, learning, and the nature of coaching itself.

In the beginning, I thought I’d be teaching the machine. In reality, the machine was teaching me—about leadership, learning, and the nature of coaching itself.

Content

AI coaching isn’t about algorithms. It’s about creating safe spaces for growth. It’s about giving more people access to development , not just a privileged few. It’s about ensuring that what emerges from the code still carries authenticity, humanity, and care.

AI coaching isn’t about algorithms. It’s about creating safe spaces for growth. It’s about giving more people access to development, not just a privileged few. It’s about ensuring that what emerges from the code still carries authenticity, humanity, and care.

Content

That paradox is what makes this moment so exciting. The more we use AI to scale learning, the more we’re reminded of the qualities that can’t be automated: empathy, trust, and human connection.

That paradox is what makes this moment so exciting. The more we use AI to scale learning, the more we’re reminded of the qualities that can’t be automated: empathy, trust, and human connection.

Content

So yes, the future of coaching may be powered by technology. But at its best, it reminds us that the real work—helping people grow into their potential—has always been, a nd will always be, profoundly human.

So yes, the future of coaching may be powered by technology. But at its best, it reminds us that the real work—helping people grow into their potential—has always been, and will always be, profoundly human.

ATD education promo card for the Applying AI in L&D Workshops. Enroll today and get a free copy of Josh Cavalier's book!

Content

You've Reached ATD Member-only Content

Become an ATD member to continue

Already a member?Sign In


Copyright © 2026 ATD

ASTD changed its name to ATD to meet the growing needs of a dynamic, global profession.

Terms of UsePrivacy NoticeCookie Policy