Do Zero-Tolerance Antibullying and Antiharassment Policies Work?

Content

I was relieved when President Biden told his incoming staff , “If you’re ever working with me and I hear you treating another colleague with disrespect, talking down to someone, I will fire you on the spot. . . . Everybody is entitled to be treated with decency and dignity.” If only more CEOs took a strong stance on appropriate behavior.

I was relieved when President Biden told his incoming staff, “If you’re ever working with me and I hear you treating another colleague with disrespect, talking down to someone, I will fire you on the spot. . . . Everybody is entitled to be treated with decency and dignity.” If only more CEOs took a strong stance on appropriate behavior.

Content

Everybody is entitled to be treated with decency and dignity, but the effectiveness of zero-tolerance policies is worth a discussion.

Everybody is entitled to be treated with decency and dignity, but the effectiveness of zero-tolerance policies is worth a discussion.

Content

First, in my experience most organizations aren’t following their core values or their harassment prevention policy, so this added layer of zero tolerance is a big pill for most of them to swallow. I suspect for many that it would be a promise the organization just can’t keep.

First, in my experience most organizations aren’t following their core values or their harassment prevention policy, so this added layer of zero tolerance is a big pill for most of them to swallow. I suspect for many that it would be a promise the organization just can’t keep.

Content

Zero tolerance tends to refer to automatic discharge of any violators regardless of mitigating factors or severity. If zero tolerance means a one-size-fits-all approach and every instance brings the same level of discipline, many will hesitate to report bad behavior for fear of the perpetrator losing their job. Generally, targets just want the behavior to stop, not to get people fired.

Zero tolerance tends to refer to automatic discharge of any violators regardless of mitigating factors or severity. If zero tolerance means a one-size-fits-all approach and every instance brings the same level of discipline, many will hesitate to report bad behavior for fear of the perpetrator losing their job. Generally, targets just want the behavior to stop, not to get people fired.

Content

Second, zero-tolerance policies also assume the problematic behavior is the individual’s fault and that the person should take full responsibility for it.

Second, zero-tolerance policies also assume the problematic behavior is the individual’s fault and that the person should take full responsibility for it.

Content

Human behavior isn’t that simple, however, and context matters more than most employers acknowledge. The Equal Employment Opportunity Committee, for example, provides a long list of organizational factors that facilitate harassment .

Human behavior isn’t that simple, however, and context matters more than most employers acknowledge. The Equal Employment Opportunity Committee, for example, provides a long list of organizational factors that facilitate harassment.

Content

In my work as an executive coach to leaders who engage in bullying, I’ve identified many organizational problems that led an individual down the path of bullying. A lack of feedback is one example. If the leader had received feedback earlier on in their journey to bad behavior, the problem would have been easier to resolve at that earlier point in time.

In my work as an executive coach to leaders who engage in bullying, I’ve identified many organizational problems that led an individual down the path of bullying. A lack of feedback is one example. If the leader had received feedback earlier on in their journey to bad behavior, the problem would have been easier to resolve at that earlier point in time.

Content

The organizations not providing honest feedback to leaders who bully are also not training leaders, managers, or supervisors in the art of delivering effective feedback. If the leader had been trained in delivering feedback, perhaps they would be delivering it well instead of through bullying behavior. In other words, a positive workplace culture includes a culture of constructive feedback.

The organizations not providing honest feedback to leaders who bully are also not training leaders, managers, or supervisors in the art of delivering effective feedback. If the leader had been trained in delivering feedback, perhaps they would be delivering it well instead of through bullying behavior. In other words, a positive workplace culture includes a culture of constructive feedback.

Content

Third, where are the managers in all this zero-tolerance promotion? Isn’t it their jobs to manage behavior and performance? It may be better, given the gray areas that come with human behavior, for managers to learn how to spot negative behavior, weigh the seriousness of it, mediate conflict when appropriate, and coach employees who regularly behave in exclusive or disrespectful ways.

Third, where are the managers in all this zero-tolerance promotion? Isn’t it their jobs to manage behavior and performance? It may be better, given the gray areas that come with human behavior, for managers to learn how to spot negative behavior, weigh the seriousness of it, mediate conflict when appropriate, and coach employees who regularly behave in exclusive or disrespectful ways.

Content

Fourth, zero-tolerance policies probably violate many organizations’ core values. If your company’s core values include innovation, inclusivity, or customer service, for example, strict adherence to rules is contradictory.

Fourth, zero-tolerance policies probably violate many organizations’ core values. If your company’s core values include innovation, inclusivity, or customer service, for example, strict adherence to rules is contradictory.

Content

Instead of zero-tolerance policies, smart organizations understand that true prevention of bullying and harassment comes from training in areas like giving feedback, coaching, communication skills, respectful workplace behaviors, internal customer service, and more. Smart organizations conduct climate assessments to understand what employees need and address those needs swiftly.

Instead of zero-tolerance policies, smart organizations understand that true prevention of bullying and harassment comes from training in areas like giving feedback, coaching, communication skills, respectful workplace behaviors, internal customer service, and more. Smart organizations conduct climate assessments to understand what employees need and address those needs swiftly.

Content

Smart organizations also hold people accountable to behaving in ways that are inclusive, respectful, and civil. When people step out of line, the culture of feedback kicks in and people feel comfortable to discuss the situation so it can be resolved.

Smart organizations also hold people accountable to behaving in ways that are inclusive, respectful, and civil. When people step out of line, the culture of feedback kicks in and people feel comfortable to discuss the situation so it can be resolved.

Content

Bad behavior is not an HR problem to be resolved with zero-tolerance policies. It’s an organizational culture problem to be resolved by experts in organizational development and change in partnership with leaders, HR, and the entire workforce.

Bad behavior is not an HR problem to be resolved with zero-tolerance policies. It’s an organizational culture problem to be resolved by experts in organizational development and change in partnership with leaders, HR, and the entire workforce.