Education's Collage of Subsidies

Content

I was thinking about Clark's (the other Clark) post on learner rights, and then the broader learner marketplace. One of the trickiest parts about development of formal learning programs is that so often, the learner only has a passing relationship to the cost of the program.

I was thinking about Clark's (the other Clark) post on learner rights, and then the broader learner marketplace. One of the trickiest parts about development of formal learning programs is that so often, the learner only has a passing relationship to the cost of the program.

Content

Enterprise Programs

Enterprise Programs

Content

Enterprise training programs are paid by the corporate, military, or government sponsor.

Enterprise training programs are paid by the corporate, military, or government sponsor.

Content

Their goal is usually some form of increased productivity or compliance.

Their goal is usually some form of increased productivity or compliance.

Content

Any vendor has to care more about meeting the need of the training director , and the training sponsor , than the end learner. Even the cost of the classroom environment is often subsidized by the enterprise, penalizing e-learning, outside classes, or even training outsourcing.

Any vendor has to care more about meeting the need of the training director, and the training sponsor, than the end learner. Even the cost of the classroom environment is often subsidized by the enterprise, penalizing e-learning, outside classes, or even training outsourcing.

Content

K-12

K-12

Content

K-12 schools are paid by taxpayers , not the students of course, nor even the family directly (even a family that goes on lavish vacations, for example, gets their education subsidized (of course if they have big houses, they also big property taxes; and then there is the private school whammy, where they are paying twice...).).

K-12 schools are paid by taxpayers, not the students of course, nor even the family directly (even a family that goes on lavish vacations, for example, gets their education subsidized (of course if they have big houses, they also big property taxes; and then there is the private school whammy, where they are paying twice...).).

Content

As we are also learning, some K-12 activity is subsidized by softdrink/juice/water vendors , that come with strings attached.

As we are also learning, some K-12 activity is subsidized by softdrink/juice/water vendors, that come with strings attached.

Content

There are grant based subsidies that push activities in one way or another.

There are grant based subsidies that push activities in one way or another.

Content

And there are more subtle subsidies, making land cheaper than building supplies or technology, relative to other building projects.

And there are more subtle subsidies, making land cheaper than building supplies or technology, relative to other building projects.

Content

Of course, K-12 is required of students, which can be considered an anti-subsidy (increasing its cost to the student, while still interfering with the learner marketplace ). Lack of choice for any required course also represents an anti-subsidy.

Of course, K-12 is required of students, which can be considered an anti-subsidy (increasing its cost to the student, while still interfering with the learner marketplace). Lack of choice for any required course also represents an anti-subsidy.

Content

College

College

Content

In many college situation, parents significantly augment the students' ability pay at least some of the tuition. Then there are scholarships for academic, sports, and music. And scholarships, like other endowments, are subsidies by alums , meaning schools have to do things specifically to keep alums happy (while students do certain things to meet the criteria of the scholarship), not necessarily in the interest of the students. Furthermore, the reason many students put up with schools is to get better jobs, which means that while corporations might subsidize universities directly, they anti-subsidize them indirectly. Any certification, in fact, is anti-subsidized by the organization that values it

In many college situation, parents significantly augment the students' ability pay at least some of the tuition. Then there are scholarships for academic, sports, and music. And scholarships, like other endowments, are subsidies by alums, meaning schools have to do things specifically to keep alums happy (while students do certain things to meet the criteria of the scholarship), not necessarily in the interest of the students. Furthermore, the reason many students put up with schools is to get better jobs, which means that while corporations might subsidize universities directly, they anti-subsidize them indirectly. Any certification, in fact, is anti-subsidized by the organization that values it

Content

These are just a few examples from the K-12, Higher Ed, and enterprise world. But every subsidy and anti-subsidy distorts the natural value proposition away from the learner marketplace. Getting over all of these will be our challenge for the decade.

These are just a few examples from the K-12, Higher Ed, and enterprise world. But every subsidy and anti-subsidy distorts the natural value proposition away from the learner marketplace. Getting over all of these will be our challenge for the decade.

Content

Note: This blog post has been subsidized by my most recent book, Learning By Doing. New book review here .

Note: This blog post has been subsidized by my most recent book, Learning By Doing. New book review here.