ATD Blog

Half of SES Report Low Morale

Wed May 21 2014

Content

The Senior Executives Association recently released a report of the results of its February member survey of Senior Executives (SES) and Senior Professionals (SP) from across the government regarding their agencies' FY 2013 performance appraisal process and outcomes. The survey provided a wide variety of information on the status, outcomes, issues, and concerns surrounding performance management in their agencies.

Content

A majority (51%) of survey respondents rated overall morale among Senior Executives and Senior Professionals at their agencies as "low or very low." Moreover, just over one-third (34 percent) reported being "not satisfied" with their agencies' FY 2013 performance appraisal and rating processes, with more than twice as many opining that the FY 2013 process was not as good as the FY 2012 process (as opposed to being better).

Content

Respondents were encouraged to provide written comments on a variety of issues, including satisfaction with their agencies' performance management process and outcomes, how such processes can be improved, and what additionally SEA can do to promote improved executive performance appraisal processes and outcomes across the government. The survey also asked employees to assess and comment on the overall state of morale among executives in their agencies.

Content

Included among the topics reflected most prominently in the comments were the following issues and concerns:

Content
Deteriorating pay for performance is unfair and causing big problems.
Deteriorating pay for performance is unfair and causing big problems.
Content
Pay Compression and pay overlap is getting out of hand and is adversely impacting SES retention.
Pay Compression and pay overlap is getting out of hand and is adversely impacting SES retention.
Content
Lack of respect and appreciation for career executives is hurting morale and agency performance.
Lack of respect and appreciation for career executives is hurting morale and agency performance.
Content
SES performance appraisal processes are seen as slow, burdensome and not transparent.
SES performance appraisal processes are seen as slow, burdensome and not transparent.
Content
SEA is seen as a force for positive change and for protecting career SES and SPs from further denigration.
SEA is seen as a force for positive change and for protecting career SES and SPs from further denigration.

Content

In reviewing the results SEA President Carol Bonosaro remarked, "The survey provides rich insights into current challenges and concerns facing the career executive corps, not only in the pay and performance management arena but more broadly in other areas impacting agencies' ability to recruit, retain and motivate career leaders. We urge the Administration and Congress to carefully consider the impact of current, shortsighted pay for performance practices on career leadership – the very leadership which is essential to efficient, effective management and to innovation in these challenging times. We can't afford a system which is essentially broken and highly demoralizing."