ATD Blog
Is “Manage” a Dirty Word?
Mon Oct 06 2014
Content
A few weeks ago, I bumped into an old friend at the mall. She is the director of customer service for a manufacturing firm. Here is a snippet of the conversation we had:
A few weeks ago, I bumped into an old friend at the mall. She is the director of customer service for a manufacturing firm. Here is a snippet of the conversation we had:
Content
“How are you?” I asked.
“How are you?” I asked.
Content
“I’m managing... “
“I’m managing... “
Content
Her reply lingered in my thoughts and triggered me to want to take a closer look at the word “manage.” I was compelled to look it up, and here’s what I found on Dictionary.com:
Her reply lingered in my thoughts and triggered me to want to take a closer look at the word “manage.” I was compelled to look it up, and here’s what I found on Dictionary.com:
Content
man·age
man·age
Content
\[man-ij\] Show IPA
\[man-ij\] Show IPA
Content
verb (used with object), man·aged, man·ag·ing.
verb (used with object), man·aged, man·ag·ing.
Content
1. to bring about or succeed in accomplishing, sometimes despite difficulty or hardship: She managed to see the governor. How does she manage it on such a small income?
1. to bring about or succeed in accomplishing, sometimes despite difficulty or hardship: She managed to see the governor. How does she manage it on such a small income?
Content
2. to take charge or care of: to manage my investments.
2. to take charge or care of: to manage my investments.
Content
3. to dominate or influence (a person) by tact, flattery, or artifice: He manages the child with exemplary skill.
3. to dominate or influence (a person) by tact, flattery, or artifice: He manages the child with exemplary skill.
Content
4. to handle, direct, govern, or control in action or use: She managed the boat efficiently.
4. to handle, direct, govern, or control in action or use: She managed the boat efficiently.
Content
5. to wield (a weapon, tool, etc.).
5. to wield (a weapon, tool, etc.).
Content
None of those definitions feel particularly appealing. They sound arduous, laborious, forceful, and heavy. In other words, they sound barely okay.
None of those definitions feel particularly appealing. They sound arduous, laborious, forceful, and heavy. In other words, they sound barely okay.
Content
And yet, managing is the job we give to the elite in organizations as a reward for their dedication and talent. It’s the title we give to people who are meant to hold the company together and make it all happen.
And yet, managing is the job we give to the elite in organizations as a reward for their dedication and talent. It’s the title we give to people who are meant to hold the company together and make it all happen.
Content
Historically, management was held up as a position to be proud of and one that carried some level of prestige and accomplishment. It has always been a position to move towards on the corporate ladder and has been given to individuals who demonstrate leadership qualities.
Historically, management was held up as a position to be proud of and one that carried some level of prestige and accomplishment. It has always been a position to move towards on the corporate ladder and has been given to individuals who demonstrate leadership qualities.
Content
Consider the often-heard phrase, “He does a great job of managing his people.” Here, the term “manage” implies the act of controlling the behavior of others in order to achieve some goal. Is control akin to leadership? Perhaps it’s time we look at management a little more closely.
Consider the often-heard phrase, “He does a great job of managing his people.” Here, the term “manage” implies the act of controlling the behavior of others in order to achieve some goal. Is control akin to leadership? Perhaps it’s time we look at management a little more closely.
Content
A multitude of best-selling books have been written about leadership. A couple of well-known favorites include Good to Great by Jim Collins and Leadership and Self-Deception by the Arbinger Institute. While they all come at leadership from a different point of view, they all agree on one basic premise: effective leadership is the key success factor in world-class organizations.
A multitude of best-selling books have been written about leadership. A couple of well-known favorites include Good to Great by Jim Collins and Leadership and Self-Deception by the Arbinger Institute. While they all come at leadership from a different point of view, they all agree on one basic premise: effective leadership is the key success factor in world-class organizations.
Content
The question that surfaces from all this review is whether or not managing is truly a leadership quality.
The question that surfaces from all this review is whether or not managing is truly a leadership quality.
Content
Let’s look at a short-list of the responsibilities that managers are typically charged with:
Let’s look at a short-list of the responsibilities that managers are typically charged with:
Content
ensuring that employees meet or exceed performance standards
ensuring that employees meet or exceed performance standards
Content
·overseeing compliance with the policies, rules, and regulations of the corporation
·overseeing compliance with the policies, rules, and regulations of the corporation
Content
building harmony amongst team members
building harmony amongst team members
Content
delivering top-notch customer service
delivering top-notch customer service
Content
growing profit margin.
growing profit margin.
Content
If we look at these responsibilities from the perspective of the corporation, one critical skill touches each responsibility: getting the best out of each individual on the team. Does managing people achieve that goal? More important, if the traditional definition is taken into consideration, managing people may not serve to achieve the set objective. Indeed, “domination, control, governing, and wielding” are not conducive to getting the best out of anyone.
If we look at these responsibilities from the perspective of the corporation, one critical skill touches each responsibility: getting the best out of each individual on the team. Does managing people achieve that goal? More important, if the traditional definition is taken into consideration, managing people may not serve to achieve the set objective. Indeed, “domination, control, governing, and wielding” are not conducive to getting the best out of anyone.
Content
I propose that seeing the best in team members and sharing that vision might just be a far more effective approach. Creating an environment where team members are invited to step up and rewarded for their initiative while trusting them to bring the very best of themselves to the table every day. This model of leadership will achieve more than “governing, controlling, or dominating” their every action.
I propose that seeing the best in team members and sharing that vision might just be a far more effective approach. Creating an environment where team members are invited to step up and rewarded for their initiative while trusting them to bring the very best of themselves to the table every day. This model of leadership will achieve more than “governing, controlling, or dominating” their every action.
Content
Look around your organization, your family, and your relationships—just how much managing is going on? Perhaps a different approach might yield the results you seek.
Look around your organization, your family, and your relationships—just how much managing is going on? Perhaps a different approach might yield the results you seek.