ATD Blog
Selecting and Implementing Performance Improvement Solutions: Influence Hypothesis
Fri Jul 11 2014
Content
Imagine that you are a performance consultant working inside an organization or as an external consultant. You have been analyzing business goals, performance gaps, root causes and influences, and the performance environment—a complete front-end analysis.
Imagine that you are a performance consultant working inside an organization or as an external consultant. You have been analyzing business goals, performance gaps, root causes and influences, and the performance environment—a complete front-end analysis.
Content
Now you need to prioritize your findings and match them to potential solutions. You have tons of quantitative and qualitative data. How can you make sense of it? How can you prioritize the potential solutions to maximize impact on the performance gaps and business goals? Eventually, you will need to consolidate the data and make recommendations.
Now you need to prioritize your findings and match them to potential solutions. You have tons of quantitative and qualitative data. How can you make sense of it? How can you prioritize the potential solutions to maximize impact on the performance gaps and business goals? Eventually, you will need to consolidate the data and make recommendations.
Content
Start by creating an influence hypothesis.
Start by creating an influence hypothesis.
Content
What is an influence hypothesis? The dictionary definition of a hypothesis is an idea or theory that is not proven but leads to further study or discussion. It is a tentative assumption about the problem or situation that you are facing. An influence hypothesis is a document that helps you organize the collected data into categories. It helps confirm that your data is correct and prioritized so you can match solutions to the performance needs.
What is an influence hypothesis? The dictionary definition of a hypothesis is an idea or theory that is not proven but leads to further study or discussion. It is a tentative assumption about the problem or situation that you are facing. An influence hypothesis is a document that helps you organize the collected data into categories. It helps confirm that your data is correct and prioritized so you can match solutions to the performance needs.
Content
What categories should your influence hypothesis include? I like to start with Thomas Gilbert’s root cause categories from his book Human Competence (1978):
What categories should your influence hypothesis include? I like to start with Thomas Gilbert’s root cause categories from his book Human Competence (1978):
Content
information (data)
information (data)
Content
instrumentation (resources, tools, processes)
instrumentation (resources, tools, processes)
Content
motivation (incentives and consequences)
motivation (incentives and consequences)
Content
motives (motivation to work)
motives (motivation to work)
Content
capacity (getting the right person)
capacity (getting the right person)
Content
wellness
wellness
Content
knowledge (building knowledge and skills needed for performance).
knowledge (building knowledge and skills needed for performance).
Content
ATD’s human performance improvement model includes these categories for cause analysis. Performance DNA, ATD’s updated human performance improvement analysis model, takes them and expands on them in influence analysis. The performance DNA methodology helps you organize your analysis data and identify the positive and negative influences on performance.
ATD’s human performance improvement model includes these categories for cause analysis. Performance DNA, ATD’s updated human performance improvement analysis model, takes them and expands on them in influence analysis. The performance DNA methodology helps you organize your analysis data and identify the positive and negative influences on performance.
Content
Influences generally fall into these categories:
Influences generally fall into these categories:
Content
general influences (work processes, redundancies, lack of inputs)
general influences (work processes, redundancies, lack of inputs)
Content
workplace and structural influences (working conditions, tools and equipment, distractions, safety, ergonomics, workload, teamwork)
workplace and structural influences (working conditions, tools and equipment, distractions, safety, ergonomics, workload, teamwork)
Content
learning and development (training access, lack of connection to performance, timing, access to subject matter experts)
learning and development (training access, lack of connection to performance, timing, access to subject matter experts)
Content
talent acquisition (recruiting for specific skills, orientation and support, compensation and benefits)
talent acquisition (recruiting for specific skills, orientation and support, compensation and benefits)
Content
managerial and structural support (access to manager, communication, control, reporting structure, performance expectations, feedback)
managerial and structural support (access to manager, communication, control, reporting structure, performance expectations, feedback)
Content
personal motivation (workload, job meaning, negative consequences, lack of consequences and incentives, level of authority, variety)
personal motivation (workload, job meaning, negative consequences, lack of consequences and incentives, level of authority, variety)
Content
technology (mismatched requirements, challenges, functionality, usability, effectiveness).
technology (mismatched requirements, challenges, functionality, usability, effectiveness).
Content
Influence hypothesis helps you confirm or deny the hypotheses about what is influencing performance (both positively and negatively) so that you can choose the best solutions to close the performance gap.
Influence hypothesis helps you confirm or deny the hypotheses about what is influencing performance (both positively and negatively) so that you can choose the best solutions to close the performance gap.
Content
In part 3 of this blog series, we will provide an example of using an influence hypothesis to guide solution selection.
In part 3 of this blog series, we will provide an example of using an influence hypothesis to guide solution selection.
Content
In part 4, we will discuss how you can engage the business unit manager in choosing performance-linked solutions.
In part 4, we will discuss how you can engage the business unit manager in choosing performance-linked solutions.
Content
In part 5, we will look at implementing performance-linked solutions.
In part 5, we will look at implementing performance-linked solutions.
Content
To explore selecting and implementing performance improvement solutions, please join me for Selecting and Implementing Performance Improvement Solutions (SIPIS) beginning December 1 in New York, New York!
To explore selecting and implementing performance improvement solutions, please join me for Selecting and Implementing Performance Improvement Solutions (SIPIS) beginning December 1 in New York, New York!