logo image

ATD Blog

The Challenge of Taking Over Leadership of an Existing Team


Mon Jan 05 2015

The Challenge of Taking Over Leadership of an Existing Team


As the outsider, you’ve got to figure out who’s who on the team. Meanwhile, you’re going to be hot on the trail of figuring out what’s what. If you are new to the entire organization, you’ve got an extra layer of orientation and learning to do. In any event, you need to learn the nuts and bolts of your new job and then start learning the nuts and bolts of the job of every one of your direct reports. If you are also a new employee, you need to be welcomed, introduced, onboarded, oriented, and brought up-to-speed.


Gather Information

While your new employer likely offers a new hire orientation program, it is often sparse and inadequate, especially to get up to speed in a leadership role. Start looking for resources from which you can start teaching yourself:

  • the organization’s big picture: its vision, mission, values, and culture

  • where your team fits in the organization

  • the work of your new team

  • broad performance standards and workplace expectations

  • company systems, practices, procedures.

As you are doing all this learning, never forget that your first and foremost responsibility will be managing your new direct reports.

Hold Team Meetings

Everyone on your team is going to be wondering: “Who are you?” “What are your plans?” “How will you manage?” and “What will it all mean for me?”


Because you are the outsider and new to everyone, it’s important to have a series of team meetings in the early stages of your new regime. You need a forum where you can say the same things to everybody in the same way at the same time, in which everybody can speak on the record in front of each other, hear each other, and respond spontaneously.

You need the light of public disclosure and discussion—at least for a little while. Depending on the group dynamics, more or less information may come out in a team meeting format. My advice to new managers in this situation is stage a series of brainstorming sessions around three questions:

  1. What should change about how our team operates?

  2. What should not change?

  3. If you were suddenly the team manager, what would your first, second and third priorities be? 

The ground rules are simple: Everybody is required to participate. Comments must be about work performance only, not about personal traits and characteristics of any individual. I recommend sitting in a circle if the group is not too big. That way you can go around the circle (clockwise or counterclockwise) for each question, getting everyone to respond to the first; then everyone responds to the second; and then the third. Depending on the size of the group and the amount of baggage people are carrying, this can take hours. You might want to split it into three separate sessions.

You will gather key data from your new team about what they think is working and what they think is not working. At the same time, you’ll learn so much about each of them and their working relationships from their responses to these questions. Take notes in these sessions, with special note of any point from one of your new employees that you’d like to follow up on in a one-on-one discussion. These follow-up discussions will reinforce to your new direct-reports that you are listening and taking their input seriously.

Meet One-on-One with Team Members


As you start your substantive one-on-ones in earnest, your first mission with every direct report will be to get up-to-speed on the fundamentals of his job. Ask, what are his current projects, tasks and responsibilities? For each meeting:

  • review examples of past work product, and work in progress

  • review background materials, standard operating procedures, instructions, manuals, checklists, or other job aids, such as frequently asked questions

  • talk to key people inside and outside the team with whom the employee works regularly.

  • look for opportunities to shadow the employee and watch him do the work.

Meet much more often with every person at first. With this systematic approach, you will get up-to-speed in a matter of weeks and be in a position to provide at least some guidance and support. Over time, your conversations will become more knowledgeable and your ability to give direction increasingly acute.

You will be amazed at how quickly you can get yourself up to full operating capacity as a manager in this way.

You've Reached ATD Member-only Content

Become an ATD member to continue

Already a member?Sign In


Copyright © 2024 ATD

ASTD changed its name to ATD to meet the growing needs of a dynamic, global profession.

Terms of UsePrivacy NoticeCookie Policy