logo image

ATD Blog

What Plan Nine From Outer Space Taught Me NOT to Do in Training


Fri Nov 06 2020

What Plan Nine From Outer Space Taught Me NOT to Do in Training

I want to talk about what my love for bad movies has taught me about training design and delivery. I love a bad film like the classic Plan Nine from Outer Space. This movie was directed by who many critics consider the worst filmmaker in film history: Ed Wood. Wood’s low-budget classic about aliens attempting to invade Earth by resurrecting the dead has a cult following and turned into a musical. Johnny Depp even starred as Ed Wood in a 1993 biopic.

So, what does a bad movie share with lousy training? You can probably think of many ways, but here are my top three.


1) Plot? There’s a Plot?

If you have seen Plan Nine, I wouldn’t blame you for being confused. Scenes happen randomly; night turns into day and then back again; and the movie just ends. Other bad filmmakers are even worse at continuity. Godfrey Ho, a maker of many bad ninja features, is famous for slamming several partially finished movies together into one confusing mess of a film.

You and I have probably been in training where there isn’t a clear structure that flows from the learning objectives (if there are learning objectives). Topics are introduced then dropped as the trainer takes you on another unrelated tangent. You can’t remember much of what you learned because you have no structure to hang the concepts on.

2) Lots and Lots of Exposition

A hallmark of bad films is the exposition scene. In Plan Nine, there are three scenes in which the actors tell others what is going—long scenes when they simply talk. In From Hell It Came, (about a killer tree; yes, a killer tree), half the movie comprises long stretches of exposition. Good time to go for some popcorn!

When I create training, I keep my content portions to 10 minutes or less. For every content portion, I want to have some interaction to keep the learners’ attention and participation. I have been in training sessions where it is all interaction and little content. That kind of training feels like a bad action film where the audience doesn’t have a moment to catch their breath (for example, Ballistic: Ecks vs. Sever). Thus, strive for the right balance of content and learning activities.

3) Padding the Film With Stock Footage

Ed Wood was a master of finding stock footage to help lengthen his films to acceptable running times. He and so many other bad filmmakers would include scenes with a tenuous relation to the film. Roger Corman, a famous B-movie director, would often use stock footage from his other films to pad his latest creations. It saved him time, and Corman became known for creating movies in two to three days.


I have also created training using content from earlier training sessions or off-the-shelf training materials. However, there is a fine line between repurposing training materials and cutting and pasting a training course. Is the repurposed training content appropriate for the session? Has the repurposed training content been updated if necessary? And do you have more new material than repurposed training content?

Bad films Can Be Fun, but Bad Training Is the Real Horror

Watching bad films can be fun. Bad films are entertaining and inadvertently comical. But while you want your training to be entertaining, you also want the training to be useful. Build your training sessions with a good structure, an optimal balance of content and interactions, and fresh content so your training is an Oscar winner instead of the training world’s Plan Nine From Outer Space.

You've Reached ATD Member-only Content

Become an ATD member to continue

Already a member?Sign In


Copyright © 2024 ATD

ASTD changed its name to ATD to meet the growing needs of a dynamic, global profession.

Terms of UsePrivacy NoticeCookie Policy