ATD, association for talent development

TD Magazine Article

Member Benefit

Think Before You Believe

Content

A review of Nine Lies About Work: A Freethinking Leader’s Guide to the Real World by Marcus Buckingham and Ashley Goodall

A review of Nine Lies About Work: A Freethinking Leader’s Guide to the Real World by Marcus Buckingham and Ashley Goodall

By

Wed May 01 2019

Loading...

Content

Nine Lies About Work: A Freethinking Leader's Guide to the Real World

Nine Lies About Work: A Freethinking Leader's Guide to the Real World

Think Before You Believe-TD_May19_books1.jpg

Content

By Marcus Buckingham and Ashley Goodall

By Marcus Buckingham and Ashley Goodall

Content

Harvard Business Review Press, 256 pp., $30

Harvard Business Review Press, 256 pp., $30

Content

A successful company has a great culture. It has a strategic plan in place complete with SMART (specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, and time-bound) goals that measure performance. It encourages employees to fix their weaknesses. It knows that its employees crave feedback and work-life balance and that the best employees are well rounded. Above all, a successful company knows that "leadership is a thing."

A successful company has a great culture. It has a strategic plan in place complete with SMART (specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, and time-bound) goals that measure performance. It encourages employees to fix their weaknesses. It knows that its employees crave feedback and work-life balance and that the best employees are well rounded. Above all, a successful company knows that "leadership is a thing."

Content

All lies. According to Buckingham and Goodall, lies are rampant in the corporate world. Research has shown us time and again that if people are invested in their jobs and care about their work, they'll be more productive and engaged. Thus, companies spend billions of dollars on technology and management practices to measure productivity and performance. In fact, these systems are so deeply ingrained into businesses that it's hard to imagine working without them. Yet they are fundamentally flawed. Ironically, current systems have succeeded in doing the very things they set out not to do: limit potential, inhibit talent, and stifle growth. What's more, these lies are so pervasive that the average person can't distinguish between what's true and what's not.

All lies. According to Buckingham and Goodall, lies are rampant in the corporate world. Research has shown us time and again that if people are invested in their jobs and care about their work, they'll be more productive and engaged. Thus, companies spend billions of dollars on technology and management practices to measure productivity and performance. In fact, these systems are so deeply ingrained into businesses that it's hard to imagine working without them. Yet they are fundamentally flawed. Ironically, current systems have succeeded in doing the very things they set out not to do: limit potential, inhibit talent, and stifle growth. What's more, these lies are so pervasive that the average person can't distinguish between what's true and what's not.

Content

This book is about nine of these lies, all of which satisfy "an organization's need for control." The authors argue that individual uniqueness; a sturdy, cohesive team; less top-down planning; more meaningful attention; and goals aligned with individual purposes are the "truths" of work.

This book is about nine of these lies, all of which satisfy "an organization's need for control." The authors argue that individual uniqueness; a sturdy, cohesive team; less top-down planning; more meaningful attention; and goals aligned with individual purposes are the "truths" of work.

Content

If you're in middle management, a team leader, or consider yourself free-thinking, you'll want to read this book. But before you go so far as to define yourself as free-thinking, ponder the eight aspects introduced in chapter 1.

If you're in middle management, a team leader, or consider yourself free-thinking, you'll want to read this book. But before you go so far as to define yourself as free-thinking, ponder the eight aspects introduced in chapter 1.

Content

The authors explain that these eight aspects of employee experience are disproportionately evident in the highest-performing teams and are valid indicators of sustained team performance. Moreover, it is the team—not the culture—that is the most important experience of work.

The authors explain that these eight aspects of employee experience are disproportionately evident in the highest-performing teams and are valid indicators of sustained team performance. Moreover, it is the team—not the culture—that is the most important experience of work.

Content

Buckingham and Goodall suggest that team leaders should regularly take the time to discuss the eight aspects with each team member. "Whatever \[your employees'\] answers, you'll always be smarter because of them, and you'll always know you're paying attention to something that matters." Show your people that you care enough to talk to them about their uniqueness and where they're going, but let them figure out how to get there.

Buckingham and Goodall suggest that team leaders should regularly take the time to discuss the eight aspects with each team member. "Whatever \[your employees'\] answers, you'll always be smarter because of them, and you'll always know you're paying attention to something that matters." Show your people that you care enough to talk to them about their uniqueness and where they're going, but let them figure out how to get there.

Content

There are more lies to come. If you're looking for a refreshing read that challenges the conventional wisdom of the business world, this is a book for your shelf.

There are more lies to come. If you're looking for a refreshing read that challenges the conventional wisdom of the business world, this is a book for your shelf.

You've Reached ATD Member-only Content

Become an ATD member to continue

Already a member?Sign In

ISSUE

May 2019 - TD Magazine

View Articles

Copyright © 2026 ATD

ASTD changed its name to ATD to meet the growing needs of a dynamic, global profession.

Terms of UsePrivacy NoticeCookie Policy