ATD Blog
Choose Your Adventure: Gamification for Learning
Wed Sep 05 2018
Content
Gamification has been among the top trends for learning and development in the last couple of years. It is often advertised as the magic pill to turn your dry content into juicy engagement. However, starting with gamification may often feel like a “choose your adventure,” and most people end up with the same route: points, badges, and leaderboards. There’s a different way to navigate.
Gamification has been among the top trends for learning and development in the last couple of years. It is often advertised as the magic pill to turn your dry content into juicy engagement. However, starting with gamification may often feel like a “choose your adventure,” and most people end up with the same route: points, badges, and leaderboards. There’s a different way to navigate.
Content
Do not start with gamification and learners in mind! Start with humans at the workplace in mind—their authentic needs, motivations, and goals.
Do not start with gamification and learners in mind! Start with humans at the workplace in mind—their authentic needs, motivations, and goals.
Content
Fostering Engagement With Gamification: Review of Current Practices on Online Learning Platforms concludes that “the starting point in gamifying online education should be learners’ needs, motivations and goals, rather than a platform-centric approach that strives to use technical features to hit some pre-defined performance metrics.”
Fostering Engagement With Gamification: Review of Current Practices on Online Learning Platforms concludes that “the starting point in gamifying online education should be learners’ needs, motivations and goals, rather than a platform-centric approach that strives to use technical features to hit some pre-defined performance metrics.”
Prepping for the Adventure
Content
Before we think about game-anything, let’s attempt to answer the following fundamental questions:
Before we think about game-anything, let’s attempt to answer the following fundamental questions:
Content
What is the business goal we’re trying to achieve?
What is the business goal we’re trying to achieve?
Content
How is the result measured?
How is the result measured?
Content
Who should be involved?
Who should be involved?
Content
What performance goals would lead to the business goal?
What performance goals would lead to the business goal?
Content
What knowledge, skills, and behaviors would lead to each performance goal?
What knowledge, skills, and behaviors would lead to each performance goal?
Content
What should people be doing? What should people not be doing?
What should people be doing? What should people not be doing?
Content
Why are people not doing what they’re supposed to be doing? Why are people doing what they’re not supposed to be doing?
Why are people not doing what they’re supposed to be doing? Why are people doing what they’re not supposed to be doing?
Content
What type of performance gaps should we address?
What type of performance gaps should we address?
Content
Knowledge recall—Something that people should recall from memory.
Knowledge recall—Something that people should recall from memory.
Content
Information—Knowledge of how to use performance tools, something they do not need to memorize but apply.
Information—Knowledge of how to use performance tools, something they do not need to memorize but apply.
Content
Skills—Something that needs practice.
Skills—Something that needs practice.
Content
Motivation—People know what to do, they know how to do it, yet they’re not doing it. This may need more investigation into why.
Motivation—People know what to do, they know how to do it, yet they’re not doing it. This may need more investigation into why.
Content
Environment—Things we can’t control. Bad systems, politics, half-baked processes. What we could do, however, is connect with influencers who may have control over it. Solving this type of issue often requires in-depth business and data literacy.
Environment—Things we can’t control. Bad systems, politics, half-baked processes. What we could do, however, is connect with influencers who may have control over it. Solving this type of issue often requires in-depth business and data literacy.
Content
And finally, ask:
And finally, ask:
Content
What authentic activities would be most effective in learning?
What authentic activities would be most effective in learning?
Content
What is the minimum information or knowledge people need to complete those actions?
What is the minimum information or knowledge people need to complete those actions?
Content
I strongly recommend Cathy Moore’s action-mapping proces s to answer these questions.
I strongly recommend Cathy Moore’s action-mapping process to answer these questions.
Starting the Adventure
Content
Now that we have identified the actions people should take, we can put our game-thinking hat on. The adventure should never start with content, it should start with actions people take at the workplace to achieve their goals. Think like a game designer, act like an instructional designer! Game thinking keeps humans in mind, while solving the problems at hand.
Now that we have identified the actions people should take, we can put our game-thinking hat on. The adventure should never start with content, it should start with actions people take at the workplace to achieve their goals. Think like a game designer, act like an instructional designer! Game thinking keeps humans in mind, while solving the problems at hand.
Content
Let’s look at seven different approaches to start your adventure:
Let’s look at seven different approaches to start your adventure:
Content
On the left side of the spectrum, there is no game play. People don’t learn through game play, even if the experience is gameful. On the right side of the spectrum, it’s all about game play. People learn through playing games. Your adventure is not a fork-in-the-road decision between games or no games. Think about it as a continuous spectrum from left to right. The more game elements you include starting from the left, the more the end product will look and feel like a game.
On the left side of the spectrum, there is no game play. People don’t learn through game play, even if the experience is gameful. On the right side of the spectrum, it’s all about game play. People learn through playing games. Your adventure is not a fork-in-the-road decision between games or no games. Think about it as a continuous spectrum from left to right. The more game elements you include starting from the left, the more the end product will look and feel like a game.
Playful Design Focuses on Experience
Content
As you answered all the questions above, you may see that there is no need to waste resources on building games or gamification; however, you want the experience to feel playful. According to A Systematic Mapping on Gamification , “playful design” means using game-based aesthetics or limited usability based on game elements in non-game contexts with the purpose of drawing the user's attention. These elements are used to amuse learners and evoke an emotional response.
As you answered all the questions above, you may see that there is no need to waste resources on building games or gamification; however, you want the experience to feel playful. According to A Systematic Mapping on Gamification, “playful design” means using game-based aesthetics or limited usability based on game elements in non-game contexts with the purpose of drawing the user's attention. These elements are used to amuse learners and evoke an emotional response.
Structural Gamification Focuses on Extrinsic Motivation
Content
Karl Kapp differentiates two types of gamification in learning: structural and content. Structural gamification gamifies the learning structure, the framework outside the learning content. For example, you may add points to your video platform for people who launch learning content. People may get points for viewing and commenting on content. The content itself does not change, only the motivation to interact with the content is targeted—mostly by offering incentives.
Karl Kapp differentiates two types of gamification in learning: structural and content. Structural gamification gamifies the learning structure, the framework outside the learning content. For example, you may add points to your video platform for people who launch learning content. People may get points for viewing and commenting on content. The content itself does not change, only the motivation to interact with the content is targeted—mostly by offering incentives.
Action (Content) Gamification Focuses on Mastery
Content
Dr. Kapp refers to this type of gamification as content gamification. I often see instructional designers less experienced in game design think in content rather than in experience. Therefore, I propose calling this “action gamification,” where we focus on actions and decisions people need on the job (uncovered by Cathy Moore’s action mapping). The activity in the learning context should be aligned to the real actions.
Dr. Kapp refers to this type of gamification as content gamification. I often see instructional designers less experienced in game design think in content rather than in experience. Therefore, I propose calling this “action gamification,” where we focus on actions and decisions people need on the job (uncovered by Cathy Moore’s action mapping). The activity in the learning context should be aligned to the real actions.
Game-Based Assessments Focus on Feedback
Content
Think of game-based assessments as game show templates or simple game-play activities, often presented in multiple-choice questions. The focus of game-based assessments is on feedback and not learning new knowledge and skills. You may use these for pre-assessment or review, but usually not for presenting new content.
Think of game-based assessments as game show templates or simple game-play activities, often presented in multiple-choice questions. The focus of game-based assessments is on feedback and not learning new knowledge and skills. You may use these for pre-assessment or review, but usually not for presenting new content.
Content
From game-based assessment on to the right, we’re entering the game-based learning territory. As learning through game play gradually takes center stage on the right, the experience is very different from gamification—and that is an adventure for a different article to explore.
From game-based assessment on to the right, we’re entering the game-based learning territory. As learning through game play gradually takes center stage on the right, the experience is very different from gamification—and that is an adventure for a different article to explore.
Content
Want to learn more? Join me October 11-12 in New Orleans for the ATD Core 4 Conference .
Want to learn more? Join me October 11-12 in New Orleans for the ATD Core 4 Conference.