Seeing the Impact: Is Leadership Development Really Measurable?

Leadership development is often treated as an article of faith. As talent development professionals, we know it’s important—strong leaders inspire teams, drive innovation, and help organizations thrive. But we may work in teams and organizations where a stronger belief may be that you can’t manage what you can’t measure.

In those organizations, leadership development may be one of the first things to be reassessed when budgets tighten. What may be core business to us may be seen as a “nice to have” for the business. And that’s where measurement becomes not just a tool, but a critical pillar of our work.

For those of us motivated by the human aspects of growth, measurement can feel like a frustrating box-checking requirement, even a cynical marketing exercise. In the work of leadership development, the nuanced shifts in confidence, empathy, and collaboration don’t show up neatly in a spreadsheet. Percentages and trend lines can seem disconnected from the impacts that leadership growth can have on individuals and teams that we hear about through stories and experience through observation. But the right approach to metrics doesn’t diminish the human element—it makes it visible.

Why Measurement Matters

Measurement isn’t about reducing the complexity of leadership to a set of figures. It’s about creating discussion focuses with business leaders. Decision makers rely on data to allocate resources and prioritize initiatives, but they also recognize that those decisions are almost always made with elements of ambiguity and risk. Metrics are inputs toward the decision, not the decision itself. If drivers of leadership development can’t enter those conversations with credible, relevant metrics, they risk being sidelined or ignored.

As practitioners, we need to choose our measurements well and also think carefully about how we interpret them. They can reveal what’s working, what’s not, and where to focus effort for the greatest impact. Without measurements as part of our feedback loop, even well-intentioned programs can stagnate or drift away from organizational priorities.

What to Measure

Our frequent go-to is the post-program survey—quick, familiar, and easy to report on. But that’s just one small slice of the picture. More robust insights come from a mix of perspectives and timelines.

• 360-degree feedback to capture changes in how leaders are perceived by peers, managers, and direct reports.

• Skill demonstrations or simulations to observe applied capabilities in realistic settings.

• Business indicators such as engagement scores, retention rates, or productivity metrics linked to leader impact.

• Career progression patterns showing whether program participants take on greater responsibilities or leadership roles.

No single measure tells the full story, but taken together, they help us refine, grow, and promote our programs.

What Is It Really Telling Us?

Collecting numbers is one thing; deriving something meaningful from them is quite another. It’s tempting to highlight only the most flattering results, but credibility comes from transparency. That’s not just admitting what needs removing or improving—it means acknowledging nuance—where the data is clear, where it’s inconclusive, and where it might reflect external factors beyond the program.

Sure, measurement can tell us what’s working—and we should pause and celebrate when it does. But it does more than that— it elucidates, it challenges us, it pushes us forward. It’s something that can help us, not hinder us. Measurement isn’t just about proving the value of leadership development—it’s about improving it.

Measurement as an Influence Tool

When we develop metrics as an essential part of our programs, we build our ability to influence the business itself. Rather than just believing our work is important and influential, we develop the skills that make us influential, not just to get our budgets approved, but to contribute visibly to the organization. The story we present is now not just a hopeful tale, but a complex, thoughtful, and educated analysis—in service of shared organizational goals, company values, and employee engagement.

The goal of measurement shouldn’t be to paint a positive picture, but an informative one—giving us insights that guide our work and enhance our organizations.

For a deeper dive, join me at the OrgDev Conference for the session: Growth You Can See: Measuring & Reporting Leadership Development.

Learn how to grow top talent and drive organizational success with ATD's creating a leadership development program certificate.