Talent Development Leader
Dig Deeper
Content
Question every step of the training request process to become a true influence.
Question every step of the training request process to become a true influence.
Wed Jun 18 2025
Content
Talent development leaders must often address complex organizational challenges that demand more than just quick fixes. In conflict with that reality, stakeholders frequently approach us with ready-made solutions already in mind—solutions that may not address the root causes of their problems. Compounding the challenge, stakeholders expect TD to deliver resolutions that not only fix the problem but also drive transformative impact.
Talent development leaders must often address complex organizational challenges that demand more than just quick fixes. In conflict with that reality, stakeholders frequently approach us with ready-made solutions already in mind—solutions that may not address the root causes of their problems. Compounding the challenge, stakeholders expect TD to deliver resolutions that not only fix the problem but also drive transformative impact.
Content
Balancing such requests for quick solutions with the need to address underlying performance and business issues can become a constant source of stress for TD practitioners. As a client of mine once bemoaned, “To our leaders, we’ve just become 1-800-TRAINING.”
Balancing such requests for quick solutions with the need to address underlying performance and business issues can become a constant source of stress for TD practitioners. As a client of mine once bemoaned, “To our leaders, we’ve just become 1-800-TRAINING.”
Content
It’s difficult to tell stakeholders that the solutions they’re requesting are destined to fail. However, by skillfully asking strategic questions, TD teams can transform stakeholder interactions into opportunities for lasting impact.
It’s difficult to tell stakeholders that the solutions they’re requesting are destined to fail. However, by skillfully asking strategic questions, TD teams can transform stakeholder interactions into opportunities for lasting impact.
Content
By using powerful, solution-neutral and results-focused questions TD can influence stakeholders; helping them think more holistically about the challenges they face; align the right solutions with organizational goals; and address root causes of performance issues.
By using powerful, solution-neutral and results-focused questions TD can influence stakeholders; helping them think more holistically about the challenges they face; align the right solutions with organizational goals; and address root causes of performance issues.
Reframing the challenge
Content
Does the following request sound familiar? A vice president of customer service, Tania, contacts a TD leader to ask for a training program to improve phone agents’ ability to handle difficult customers. While the request appears to focus on a singular solution, diving into designing a training program without exploring the full context risks missing systemic issues such as unclear policies or outdated systems.
Does the following request sound familiar? A vice president of customer service, Tania, contacts a TD leader to ask for a training program to improve phone agents’ ability to handle difficult customers. While the request appears to focus on a singular solution, diving into designing a training program without exploring the full context risks missing systemic issues such as unclear policies or outdated systems.
Content
Such requests can create a cycle of reactive problem solving in which TD professionals are constantly attempting to put out fires with one-off solutions rather than addressing deeper issues. It’s an approach that not only wastes resources but can also erode the TD function’s credibility over time.
Such requests can create a cycle of reactive problem solving in which TD professionals are constantly attempting to put out fires with one-off solutions rather than addressing deeper issues. It’s an approach that not only wastes resources but can also erode the TD function’s credibility over time.
Content
To break free of the cycle, TD must strategically reframe stakeholder requests, starting with a broader exploration of the underlying needs.
To break free of the cycle, TD must strategically reframe stakeholder requests, starting with a broader exploration of the underlying needs.
Recognizing interrelated needs
Content
Every business request stems from a combination of needs that may include operational results, behavioral changes, or systemic improvements. Categorize them as follows.
Every business request stems from a combination of needs that may include operational results, behavioral changes, or systemic improvements. Categorize them as follows.
Content
Business needs, which address operational outcomes such as increased sales or improved customer satisfaction
Business needs, which address operational outcomes such as increased sales or improved customer satisfaction
Content
Performance needs, which focus on specific behaviors a business or department requires to achieve its desired results
Performance needs, which focus on specific behaviors a business or department requires to achieve its desired results
Content
Organizational capability needs, which involve system-centered factors (such as processes, tools, or incentives) that affect performance
Organizational capability needs, which involve system-centered factors (such as processes, tools, or incentives) that affect performance
Content
Individual capability needs, which focus on employee-centered factors such as skills, knowledge, or relevant experience
Individual capability needs, which focus on employee-centered factors such as skills, knowledge, or relevant experience
Content
In the earlier scenario, Tania mentions a performance need (handling difficult customer calls) and chooses an individual capability solution (training). But that is only half the picture. What business needs do phone agents’ poor handling of customer calls affect? What organizational capability factors could be adding to the problem? The stakeholder’s concern becomes an opportunity for the TD leader to help the vice president approach the issue holistically rather than through a narrow lens.
In the earlier scenario, Tania mentions a performance need (handling difficult customer calls) and chooses an individual capability solution (training). But that is only half the picture. What business needs do phone agents’ poor handling of customer calls affect? What organizational capability factors could be adding to the problem? The stakeholder’s concern becomes an opportunity for the TD leader to help the vice president approach the issue holistically rather than through a narrow lens.
Applying logic
Content
The gaps logic model is a valuable framework for diagnosing issues and aligning actions with results. It considers:
The gaps logic model is a valuable framework for diagnosing issues and aligning actions with results. It considers:
Content
Should. What is the business’s desired future state or goal?
Should. What is the business’s desired future state or goal?
Content
Is. What is the current state or reality?
Is. What is the current state or reality?
Content
Cause. What is driving the gap between should and is ?
Cause. What is driving the gap between should and is?
Content
Marry that logic with the needs (business, performance, organizational, and individual) to create an accurate and useful understanding of any challenge.
Marry that logic with the needs (business, performance, organizational, and individual) to create an accurate and useful understanding of any challenge.
Content
Business and performance needs are outcomes, so we should consider what should be for each of these needs, versus what actually is.
Business and performance needs are outcomes, so we should consider what should be for each of these needs, versus what actually is.
Content
When there is a gap between what is and what should be, look at organizational and individual capability needs as potential root causes for that gap.
When there is a gap between what is and what should be, look at organizational and individual capability needs as potential root causes for that gap.
Content
Once you ascertain what is, what should be, and the multiple causes for the gap between them, then it becomes possible to find effective solutions.
Once you ascertain what is, what should be, and the multiple causes for the gap between them, then it becomes possible to find effective solutions.
Embracing influential questioning
Content
Strategic questioning lies at the heart of shifting stakeholder conversations from transactional to transformative. Effective questions share three key attributes:
Strategic questioning lies at the heart of shifting stakeholder conversations from transactional to transformative. Effective questions share three key attributes:
Content
Open-ended. They encourage exploration rather than restricting responses to yes or no answers.
Open-ended. They encourage exploration rather than restricting responses to yes or no answers.
Content
Focused. Each question targets a specific needs category.
Focused. Each question targets a specific needs category.
Content
Solution-neutral. They avoid leading the stakeholder toward a predefined solution.
Solution-neutral. They avoid leading the stakeholder toward a predefined solution.
Content
Consider the following progression, which illustrates how to improve questions.
Consider the following progression, which illustrates how to improve questions.
Content
Purely tactical. What’s your vision for our customer service training program?
Purely tactical. What’s your vision for our customer service training program?
Content
Better. How do you need phone agents to perform differently after attending training?
Better. How do you need phone agents to perform differently after attending training?
Content
Best. How do you need phone agents to perform differently?
Best. How do you need phone agents to perform differently?
Content
The final version removes assumptions about the solution, focusing solely on the stakeholder’s desired performance outcomes.
The final version removes assumptions about the solution, focusing solely on the stakeholder’s desired performance outcomes.
Content
Apply that deliberate questioning method to the gaps logic model:
Apply that deliberate questioning method to the gaps logic model:
Content
Establish a clear context by beginning with the highest-level need the client expresses.
Establish a clear context by beginning with the highest-level need the client expresses.
Content
When the stakeholder’s only need is a solution, use a performance-focused question to shift the conversation.
When the stakeholder’s only need is a solution, use a performance-focused question to shift the conversation.
Content
Obtain detailed should and is information before delving into the causes of the gap.
Obtain detailed should and is information before delving into the causes of the gap.
Content
Address one needs category completely before moving to another.
Address one needs category completely before moving to another.
Content
Use that sequence of questions to gather information about Tania’s problem while influencing her perspective about the challenge.
Use that sequence of questions to gather information about Tania’s problem while influencing her perspective about the challenge.
Content
Performance is : You’ve expressed a concern about how phone agents are handling difficult customer calls. Can you describe what you’ve observed them doing that is a problem?
Performance is: You’ve expressed a concern about how phone agents are handling difficult customer calls. Can you describe what you’ve observed them doing that is a problem?
Content
Performance should : What do you need phone agents to do differently to successfully handle difficult customer calls?
Performance should: What do you need phone agents to do differently to successfully handle difficult customer calls?
Content
Performance cause : What factors do you think are preventing phone agents from handling calls the way you need them to?
Performance cause: What factors do you think are preventing phone agents from handling calls the way you need them to?
Content
Business is : I can understand why you’re concerned. How does less-than-optimal handling of difficult customers affect your operational metrics?
Business is: I can understand why you’re concerned. How does less-than-optimal handling of difficult customers affect your operational metrics?
Content
Business should : So that I have a complete picture of the situation, can you share your specific goals for each of those metrics?
Business should: So that I have a complete picture of the situation, can you share your specific goals for each of those metrics?
Content
Business cause : Are there other factors, in addition to the performance of your phone agents, that are preventing you from meeting your goals?
Business cause: Are there other factors, in addition to the performance of your phone agents, that are preventing you from meeting your goals?
Content
Because that scenario starts with performance needs, the questions did not transition to learning about business needs until after a complete discussion of performance should, is, and cause. Starting with a business question may confuse Tania or cause her to feel confronted.
Because that scenario starts with performance needs, the questions did not transition to learning about business needs until after a complete discussion of performance should, is, and cause. Starting with a business question may confuse Tania or cause her to feel confronted.
Content
Notice that the above example does not address the training solution Tania requested. That is an effort to lead her toward a broader, more complete consideration. That way, Tania will realize on her own that training alone will not be sufficient to produce her desired operational results. It’s an opportunity to partner with Tania—and any stakeholder who approaches you—and achieve results rather than providing plug-and-play solutions.
Notice that the above example does not address the training solution Tania requested. That is an effort to lead her toward a broader, more complete consideration. That way, Tania will realize on her own that training alone will not be sufficient to produce her desired operational results. It’s an opportunity to partner with Tania—and any stakeholder who approaches you—and achieve results rather than providing plug-and-play solutions.
Navigating common barriers
Content
Despite its effectiveness, strategic questioning is not without its challenges. TD leaders often encounter:
Despite its effectiveness, strategic questioning is not without its challenges. TD leaders often encounter:
Content
Leadership resistance. Some stakeholders may oppose diagnostic conversations, perceiving them as delays in addressing immediate needs.
Leadership resistance. Some stakeholders may oppose diagnostic conversations, perceiving them as delays in addressing immediate needs.
Content
Time constraints. The pressure to deliver quick results can make in-depth exploration seem impractical.
Time constraints. The pressure to deliver quick results can make in-depth exploration seem impractical.
Content
Client assumptions. Stakeholders may fixate on solutions they believe are necessary, limiting openness to other approaches.
Client assumptions. Stakeholders may fixate on solutions they believe are necessary, limiting openness to other approaches.
Content
To overcome those barriers, TD leaders can:
To overcome those barriers, TD leaders can:
Content
Build credibility. Demonstrating the value of diagnostic approaches through small, significant wins helps build trust.
Build credibility. Demonstrating the value of diagnostic approaches through small, significant wins helps build trust.
Content
Stay structured. Using frameworks such as the gaps logic model ensures conversations remain focused and efficient, even under time pressure.
Stay structured. Using frameworks such as the gaps logic model ensures conversations remain focused and efficient, even under time pressure.
Content
Grow sustained partnerships. Intentionally forming continuous partnerships with influential stakeholders within your organization, outside the bounds of periodic project work, can create champions for a more strategic approach.
Grow sustained partnerships. Intentionally forming continuous partnerships with influential stakeholders within your organization, outside the bounds of periodic project work, can create champions for a more strategic approach.
Content
Leaders that adopt a question-led approach see multiple benefits:
Leaders that adopt a question-led approach see multiple benefits:
Content
Aligned solutions. They represent actual needs and tie directly to business goals.
Aligned solutions. They represent actual needs and tie directly to business goals.
Content
Engaged stakeholders. They are more likely to invest in the process.
Engaged stakeholders. They are more likely to invest in the process.
Content
Efficient resource use. Higher returns emerge due to solving problems at their source.
Efficient resource use. Higher returns emerge due to solving problems at their source.
Be strategic
Content
Strategic questioning empowers TD leaders to move beyond reactive solution delivery and become influential partners in driving organizational success. By addressing underlying needs and aligning solutions with business objectives, the TD function can tackle symptoms as well as root causes of challenges.
Strategic questioning empowers TD leaders to move beyond reactive solution delivery and become influential partners in driving organizational success. By addressing underlying needs and aligning solutions with business objectives, the TD function can tackle symptoms as well as root causes of challenges.
Content
As you prepare for your next stakeholder conversation, consider the transformative power of a well-placed question. It could redefine not only the problem at hand but your entire approach to client engagement. Read more from Talent Development Leader.
As you prepare for your next stakeholder conversation, consider the transformative power of a well-placed question. It could redefine not only the problem at hand but your entire approach to client engagement.
Read more from Talent Development Leader.